The Werewolf Menace: Day 3

[TheCheese]

gamecommodore states it...go reread day two where gameguru goes to get lynched......"clearly a werewolf"

[LaughingMan]

gamecommodore states it...go reread day two where gameguru goes to get lynched......"clearly a werewolf"

GameCommodore would never let that slip, least of all in writing 
Do you really think gameguru would try that double fake with that "let's
not lynch anyone tonight"?   I don't think he was a wolf.



In any case, I think I'm going to go ahead and believe John ~~~shudder~~~shudder~~~
and second the nomination for Dr L Loki.

[Dr. L. Loki]

well this is where i get eaten, i AM the SEER. Loki is a werewolf and that is all i know to be a fact. so i nominate loki. we must get him and i think we, the villagers, will survive this onslaught.

Well played sir.  Not a bad strategy claiming to be the seer. The heat seems to be growing for you lately and then you make the announcement. I see four errors in your stratagem.

1) Two people know you to be a liar at least, the seer and me. Only a werewolf would make this play before they had all the answers.
2) You conveniently stated the non werewolves are the two only people speaking up on the boards lately. How interesting.
3) The seer has only had two opportunities to ask the identity of the werewolf, not three. The seer asks at the end of the week not the beginning.
4) The seer would expose their nature after nominations not before. That way there is no unneeded risk to themselves and their powers.
Though I wear a wool suit every day, I am not a wolf in sheep’s clothing. 

I shall nominate John, not out of retaliation, but merely through the power of deduction.  I hope calmer heads will prevail.

[batmatt]

Man, I get tied up in work ONE DAY and I miss a ton of posting.
I tend to agree with Colby though about gameguru being the Wolf1, in fact I am sure.
I haven't made my mind up yet on Loki, he's devious enough BUT Wake and I am still alive which is against his character
The MSU PACKMAN death threw me, I thought for sure it would be John or DJ then it would be clear whichever was left was the other wolf
Wake is making me nervous though...  of course if he died, Loki did it.
Walton, I am sure is not Wolf2 but if he is, well played sir.
Colby could be wolf2 but then again he ran over gameguru with a bus, so he's not it.
DJ I'm not sure of... The only way John is still alive is only if
    a. DJ is not the werewolf
    b. John & DJ are the werewolves together (then they can't kill one another)
Quite honestly, I thought DJ & John were it for that reason. Plus if you consider who died by werewolf hands ED, ELMAN(wezilla), it makes sense, which is why MSU Packman threw me
I not sure who to nominate BUT I have until Weds.

[John McLaren]

i asked after Gamecommodore died, after wezilla, and then after msupackman

[Dr. L. Loki]

i asked after Gamecommodore died, after wezilla, and then after msupackman

When I was the seer last time I played, the first time you view is while the second person is killed, not the first.  That would be wezilla, then msupackman.

[TheWake]

Man, I get tied up in work ONE DAY and I miss a ton of posting.
I tend to agree with Colby though about gameguru being the Wolf1, in fact I am sure.
I haven't made my mind up yet on Loki, he's devious enough BUT Wake and I am still alive which is against his character
The MSU PACKMAN death threw me, I thought for sure it would be John or DJ then it would be clear whichever was left was the other wolf
Wake is making me nervous though...  of course if he died, Loki did it.
Walton, I am sure is not Wolf2 but if he is, well played sir.
Colby could be wolf2 but then again he ran over gameguru with a bus, so he's not it.
DJ I'm not sure of... The only way John is still alive is only if
    a. DJ is not the werewolf
    b. John & DJ are the werewolves together (then they can't kill one another)
Quite honestly, I thought DJ & John were it for that reason. Plus if you consider who died by werewolf hands ED, ELMAN(wezilla), it makes sense, which is why MSU Packman threw me
I not sure who to nominate BUT I have until Weds.

Loki is devious enough to make sure we live long enough to throw the suspicion on everyone else, then kill us both off in one day (one lynched, one eaten).  Both of us still being alive is reason enough for me to suspect Loki.

I just have this nagging at the back of my mind that gameguru might not have been a wolf.  That is all.  I'm about 75% sure he was though.

[LaughingMan]

i asked after Gamecommodore died, after wezilla, and then after msupackman

When I was the seer last time I played, the first time you view is while the second person is killed, not the first.  That would be wezilla, then msupackman.

You're close Loki, the problem with John's explanation is that right now is after MSUPackman 
So there were only 2 nights, 2 guesses.

I should have trusted my shudders.  We are being deceived!

[TheWake]

Now everyone needs to repeat after me

"I pledge allegiance to the flag of our community and to the village for which it stands: One village, under God, indivisible, With lynchings and torture for all werewolves."

Anyone refusing to recite the pledge to our village must be a werewolf and needs to die.

[John McLaren]

if we do not win after loki dies, then by all means lynch me. it will only hurt the villagers.

[Toteboy]

i nominate loki because i he is a werewolf.

[batmatt]

i nominate loki because i he is a werewolf.

Sooooo
A father-son voting block, I must reconsider my nomination now...

[John McLaren]

Sooooo
A father-son voting block, I must reconsider my nomination now...

says the other werewolf defending his "brother"

[Dr. L. Loki]

I do not think toteboy is a werewolf.  He had not logged in for some time until now.  We know John is not the seer. That makes him a werewolf or just a villager trying to save his own skin.  (How messed up would that be?)

I think John started to see his plan backfire, and told his son to login and nominate me.

That leaves Matt and Wake to nominate someone.  I don't want to point fingers since my neck is on the line, but I think if both werewolves are left I have a good idea who is the other one. But then again I really didn't think John was until he pulled this fake seer ploy.

I feel like I am stuck in a game of paranoia.

[TheCheese]

Thats because sir you are a cylon......oops wrong game...i meant werewolf